Categories

Making your own potting compost. No Peat. No Plastic

Hints and tips on making your own potting compost without peat

Potting compost usually comes in plastic sacks from the garden centre .Compost is almost universally used for propagating plants and for growing plants and vegetables in containers. In general, it provides better and more consistent results than using garden soil as composts are usually free from weeds and diseases, contain the appropriate level of nutrients, and more free draining than most soils.

However, there are big downsides to using commercial composts as the majority still use peat as a base. The extraction of peat is a major contributor to carbon dioxide release and also has major impacts on the associated wetland habitats. Even if you buy peat-free composts the transport of such heavy materials adds to carbon emissions and they still generate plastic waste. Most peat free composts are based on forestry waste but some use coir fibre from coconut manufacture which will have travelled a long way to get to here.

For many years I have used peat free composts with mainly good results but last year decided to try and make my own. Based on just 1 year’s experiments here are my experiences.

What do you make your own compost out of? 

A little research indicated that the range of materials required is quite simple and limited. 

Basic ingredients

Leaf mould. Rotting down leaves for 1 or 2 years results in a lovely light, friable material which is low in nutrients. Merely gathering leaves after they fall in autumn and piling these into a heap contained by netting or putting them in punctured plastic sacks will yield the desired material. There is no need to turn the heap as fungi are doing the work for you. An alternative material would be composted shreddings.

Garden compost. This is generated from your compost heap. This must be well rotted and should be sieved to remove any larger pieces. After a couple of recent BOG compost workshops, the quality of our compost has improved markedly. The key is to have a good mix of materials and turn the heap regularly

Loam. This is basically garden soil. The best way to make it is to stack turfs (grass side to grass side) in piles and cover to prevent the stack drying out. After a couple of years break it up with a spade or a fork and sieve it to remove any remaining roots, stones or vegetation. Using a loam without lumps is important as the potting compost needs to be able to be compacted down to ensure that seeds or growing roots of plants are in good contact with compost.  Ideally the loam should be sterilised before use but putting trays of compost in the oven is a step too far for me! I have read that it needs to be heated to 80 deg C for 30 minutes to supress disease whilst retaining a level of micro-organisms and fungi.

Additives. The 3 components above will make up the bulk of the compost but for some composts additional nutrients need to be added (see the recipes below). I use either bonemeal, an all-round fertilizer such as Blood, fish and bone or Fertile Fibre’s nutrient base. You can also buy the John Innes fertiliser base in some garden centres. Those wanting animal free products could use seaweed meal. The important point is that is should be in powdered form rather than granulated so it can be evenly and thoroughly mixed into the composts.

Other potential ingredients

Manure. Rich composts benefit from additional nutrients and well-rotted animal manure can provide these. However, I have found the output from our heap of horse manure when rotted down is rather too wet and claggy to easily incorporate into a potting compost

Green-waste compost. This is available in some of the larger towns and cities generated from kerbside green waste collections. It has high organic matter and some nutrient value and can be added to richer composts in place of home-made compost.

Grit or sharp sand. A useful ad hoc addition to composts where addition drainage is required

Recipes

Different type of compost will be required needed depending on what it will be used for. I have made up the following 3 types:

Seed Compost. This needs to be free draining and low in nutrients

50% leaf mould (sieved)

50% loam (sieved)

A little grit/sand may also be added depending on what species is being sown

Potting-on Compost. For potting on seedling and larger plants. A good fertile mix

50% leaf mould (sieved)

50% loam (sieved)

120g general fertiliser (per roughly 20 litres of compost)

40g bone-meal (per roughly 20 litres of compost)

Lime or ground chalk (optional)

Rich Compost. Used for potting up plants and vegetables to be grown for many months or years in containers

50% loam (sieved)

25% leaf mould (sieved) 

25% garden compost or manure

Grit (optional)

All these are mixed separately in a wheelbarrow and then stored in small bins for use when needed. They can then be used as basic composts suitable for most purposes but can be tailored, if required, for specific plants.

Experiences

I was pleasantly surprised that most of the composts I made worked well. Seeds germinated just as well as in commercial composts. If anything, the seedlings once potted on into the potting-on compost, grew better than in some previously bought composts. The only significant failure was in potting up basil plants. These soon became weak and eventually died off due to what was almost certainly fusarium wilt. This is a fungal disease and I suspect was carried in the leaf mould. I had to resort to resowing the seed again in commercial seed compost. Interestingly the tomatoes grew with no problems in my potting-on compost despite being a plant that is apparently very susceptible to this disease.

In conclusion, if you can obtain the basic materials, I would definitely recommend trying out making your own composts. It is cheap, does not require much effort once you have ingredients prepared and has significant environmental benefits. Why not start in a small way, using your own compost for a few seeds and plants, and comparing the results you get with commercial composts. Please let us know the results. If you don’t have the basic ingredients then make some leaf mould and stack some turfs in preparation for compost making.